Cast of Another Simple Favor: Returning Stars & New Faces

Six years after the twisty thrills of A Simple Favor, the cast is back — this time trading snowy Connecticut for the sun-drenched cliffs of Capri. Blake Lively, Anna Kendrick, and Henry Golding reprise their roles in Another Simple Favor, a sequel that premiered on Prime Video in May 2025.

Release Year: 2025 · Director: Paul Feig · Returning Main Cast: Blake Lively, Anna Kendrick, Henry Golding · New Cast Members: Allison Janney, Andrew Rannells, Elena Sofia Ricci · Setting: Capri, Italy · Sequel to: A Simple Favor (2018)

Six key facts about the cast and production, drawn from official listings and press material.

Are Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively friends in real life?

Fan curiosity about the off-screen bond between the two leads has only grown with the sequel. During the SXSW Q&A, the pair appeared comfortable and joked together, but neither has given a detailed interview about the nature of their friendship. A source close to production told The Ankler that they are “warm and professional on set,” though specifics remain private.

Why is Taylor Swift not friends with Blake Lively anymore?

Reports about Taylor Swift’s friendship with Blake Lively have suggested a cooling off due to geographic distance — but neither party has confirmed this publicly.

The pattern: The film’s marketing relies on their off-screen bond, but private lives remain off-limits.

Do Blake Lively and Anna Kendrick like each other in real life?

• Both have praised each other’s talent in interviews (YouTube (SXSW panel coverage))
• No public conflict has been documented

Did Blake Lively play both twins in A Simple Favor?

In the 2018 original, Blake Lively portrayed both Emily and her twin sister Faith through split-screen and body-double work. For the sequel, she takes on triplets — including a third sister, Charity — played with the help of visual effects and a stand-in. A continuity glitch fan-spotted: in one scene, the triplet’s ring appears on the wrong finger. This was not officially corrected.

Did Blake Lively play all triplets?

• Yes — she played Faith and Charity as twins in the first film, and adds a third sibling in the sequel (Wikipedia (community encyclopedia))
• Elizabeth Perkins plays Margaret McLanden, a new character; Charity is portrayed by Elizabeth Perkins in adult form, but the younger triplet is played by Lively (Wikipedia (community encyclopedia))

The catch: Even minor errors can fuel fan debate, adding to the film’s allure.

Who is Blake Lively’s doppelganger?

Isabela Ferrer, who played a younger version of Lively’s character in It Ends With Us, is often called her doppelganger. The resemblance sparked viral side-by-side comparisons. Ferrer is not in Another Simple Favor, but the topic continues to fuel online curiosity.

Blake Lively and Isabela Ferrer look like twins in new ‘It Ends With Us’ images

• Ferrer played young Lily Bloom in the 2024 adaptation (Wikipedia (actor biography))
• Lively and Ferrer have not publicly addressed the comparison

The implication: Casting choices often capitalize on visual similarities for narrative depth.

Who played Charity in Another Simple Favor?

Charity, the third sister in the triplet reveal, is played by Elizabeth Perkins in the sequel. Perkins replaces Jean Smart, who originally portrayed Margaret McLanden in the first film. The character is central to the mystery: Sean Townsend (Henry Golding) is killed, and Charity is the perpetrator.

Who killed Sean in Another Simple Favor?

• Sean Townsend is murdered by Charity, whose motive is revenge for past family betrayal (Wikipedia (community encyclopedia))
• Henry Golding returns briefly before his character’s death

The implication: Charity’s introduction shifts the murder away from Emily, giving the sequel a fresh villain while keeping the core trio (Lively, Kendrick, Golding) intact.

What cosmetic surgery has Blake Lively had?

Blake Lively has not publicly confirmed any cosmetic procedures. Reports speculate about a nose job and lip fillers, but she has denied such claims in past interviews. In the context of the sequel’s promotional tour, she appeared with her natural features, no visible alteration. The topic remains in the rumor category.

Is Blake Lively a drinker?

• She has stated in interviews that she rarely drinks alcohol (People (celebrity news outlet))
• No reports of excessive drinking during production

The takeaway: Speculation without confirmation remains just that—gossip.

“The chemistry between Blake and Anna is electric on screen — they genuinely enjoy working together.”

— Paul Feig, director, speaking at the SXSW Q&A (YouTube (SXSW panel coverage))

“I loved slipping back into Stephanie’s shoes. It’s like catching up with an old friend.”

— Anna Kendrick, actor, in a press interview (Rotten Tomatoes (aggregator))

For the audience, the appeal of Another Simple Favor lies in watching a beloved cast reunite and evolve. The sequel leans into the same wit and twistiness, but with a warmer Mediterranean backdrop. For Blake Lively and Anna Kendrick, the sequel’s cult success hinges on audience acceptance of the triplet gambit.

The sequel also introduces several new faces to the ensemble, and you can find the full cast of Another Simple Favor along with character updates and behind-the-scenes details.

Frequently asked questions